posted on February 12, 2000 09:32:53 AM new
No, no one else can see your blacklist. If a blacklisted bidder trys to bid in one of your auction they will get a message like " you are not permitted to bid"
posted on February 13, 2000 07:50:51 AM new
Thank you Kimbo! That confirms it for me then. Someone is playing games with one of my friend's auctions, wish people had better things to do than to try to ruin perfect feedback with silliness. They think my friend is someone else (maybe learning to read userid's would be a good thing) and are having their friends bid on her auctions and then back out saying she blacklists bidders. My friend has only ever blacklisted one person because the person has poor feedback for non payment or exceptionally slow payment and the bidders responses are filled with swear words and threats and she didn't want to get involved with that sort of thing. My friend has perfect feedback and a loyal customer base, but this has put a nasty taste in her mouth for Yahoo now...
posted on February 13, 2000 09:28:04 PM new
UPDATE: My friend just received an email from Yahoo telling her that "commitments should be honored". She has never ever not honored a commitment either as a buyer or seller! She cancelled a bid several days BEFORE the close of auction because of the bidders extensive negative feedback profile. Then someone comes in, bids, and 3 minutes before the auction closes, uses the "send a question to the seller" option to say she wants her bid cancelled because the seller cancels bids and raises prices. And then makes a threatening statement I'd rather not say. How would this person know a bid was cancelled (or even by who - seller or buyer) and the price was never raised, the auction was just continued. I think the bidder is confused and very bored, has nothing much better to do.
Regardless, the point is moot, my friend notified Yahoo of her feelings on this and has cancelled all her auctions.
posted on February 14, 2000 06:40:20 AM new
Piece of advice that is going to cost you nothing. Don't get into a war of words with those bidders. Believe me I have seen worst. I have seen someone with oner 65 negatives. Unheard of right but Yahoo doesn't suspend someone's account. This joker has over 50 ids & rising. You can complain to Yahoo & get their standard e-mail. Report to the online fraud help desk...look they get over 100,000 such complains a day.
Why do these people do it?. Simple, they lack attention in life & they only way they know how to get it is by being a pest to society. Ignore them. Simply blacklist them. Guess what will happen, you will get more fake bidders. Trick is not to let it get to you. I have over 50 ids blacklisted & that number will rise. Look you are never going to get payment for the item so why waste your time. Are you going to beg for $15?. are you going to commit a crime for $15?. If the answer is no, simply relist the items. What else can you do?. Yahoo's great don't get me wrong but they are more concern with statistics than customer care. They love multiple ids from a statistic standpoint. Its a listed company on Wall Street right. That's why a lot of serious traders don't use Yahoo. Too bad, its really a great site.
posted on February 14, 2000 09:18:53 AM new
eddiebear2: Yahoo will give out administrative negatives on bidders who cancel bids because it is not a good practice. I can understand mistakes happen, but it is important to read a sellers feedback BEFORE you bid and not after.
As a seller, I like the fact, that if a bidder cancels their bid, it is yahoo giving the negative and not me, so it takes the heat of off me.
There is a way a couple of dishonest bidders could work together to bid an item up to discourage other bidders from bidding and then one withdrawing their high bid at the very end so the other could win the item at a low price. It is called bid shielding and this is one reason I suspect Yahoo has taken this firm stance on bid cancellations.
posted on February 15, 2000 06:47:34 AM new
Thanks for the replies!
I think the following needs to be made clear:
My friend was the SELLER in this case and cancelled a bidder's bid based on the bidder's negative feedback DAYS BEFORE the auction closed.
Bidder #2 comes in and bids on auction. With 3 minutes to go in the auction, bidder #2 uses the "ask seller a question" feature to send email to my friend stating that they want the SELLER to cancel their bid for them, stating that seller abruptly cancels bids and that this is for revenge. Obviously there is no time for the SELLER to cancel this bid and it was all just a game.
And Yahoo condones this behavior.
My friend did absolutely nothing wrong that I can see and Yahoo has made it seem that a transaction was not honored. Where was a transaction not honored? The 2nd bidder asked for the transaction to be cancelled, so even though the auction already closed with them being the winner, my friend considers the transaction cancelled because they were asked to do so.
My feeling is bidder #2 was bidding for bidder #1 and waited until the closing minutes to ask for the bid to be cancelled just to cause trouble.
posted on February 15, 2000 11:51:31 AM new
eddiebear2: I guess I was confused because I have as a seller,
cancelled bidders bids before (if they had extensive negative feedback or looked like trouble)
and I never received such an email from yahoo. I would advise your friend not to give up selling on yahoo auctions because of this one bad experience. The good bidders really do outweight the bad and we do have the option to cancel any bids we don't feel comfortable about.
Ebay is so far behind Yahoo in the ability to blacklist bidders.
What are you to do if you can't watch your ebay auctions from start to finish. It's so easy for a sniper to win at the last min there that may be totally undesirable and you have no chance to zap their bid. Of course some sellers don't worry about checking out the bidders, but I do if I have time. Who needs the trouble if it's obivious BEFORE the auction ends. If they look iffy, I give them the chance, if they are new I hope for the best, but when you see problem remarks in the feedback, look out!
posted on February 20, 2000 03:37:31 PM new
bidder 2 was probley bidder 1 with a new ID, heck you can change or have as many ID's as you want on yahoo. But I do not think the bid should have been canceled because of the bidders history. I have had some sucess in selling items to bidders with a bad history, and if they don't come through,I black list them and put the item back up for auction. Everyone is intitled to a couple mistakes (Bad rateings)
It does not mean that everything that they bid on will turn out on the negitive side. I just closed a deal with a person with 14 bad rateings, I had the check in the mail with in 4 days, it was even good.
I have also had people write me and say that they are sorry but some personal problem came up in thier life and cannot forefill the oblagation at this time. But some of us (sellers) can't take no as an answer either for what ever reason, and my give a bad rateing anyway......