posted on February 17, 2000 06:59:32 PM new
I find it suprising that people will (1) auction back-up copies of current games or other software with the lame statement that it is your right to have a back-up copy. That you should only use the software if you have a legal copy. That they are so law abiding that if they think you are going to use the software without alicense, they will not sell it to you or (2) don't mention that it is a copy and you find out after you buy it.
I wish Yahoo, e-bay etc would step in and take some reposibility and block these sales....
1/2 life seems to be under heavy attack by the the legal back-up copy sellers.
posted on February 19, 2000 12:05:15 AM new
Or the one I find most amusing is when they take all the effort to tell you exactly what is on those floppys, and then claim that they are being sold as blanks. That is a blatent crime. Yet there is some grey areas in the software wars.
What about original software that the publisher claims you can't resell? theyclaim they never sold the program, but only the right to use their software...the license. How come you never see this one challenged in court? I think because the publishers are not at all certain they would win. It's been a long tradition for people to buy and sell tangible objects. And if software gets away with it the rest of the media is soon to follow. Forget selling or even giving your music or books to anybody else. What's next, your car and house?
And what about when I buy a used version of Microsoft Money in the thrift store that says "not for resale...to be distributed only with a new PC." Do I not have the right to re-sell it? I never entered into any agreements with Microsoft or anybody else. I legally paid my $ for it and now I'll do what I damn well please with it.
I mention this because out of all the things Yahoo never does for us, one thing they did do is Microsoft's dirty work for them. The exact program I mentioned above I had for auction and the NOT for RESALE was clearly visible in the pix. Someone at Microsoft must have complained to yahoo, because that auction was cancelled in midstream without any comment or explaination.
posted on February 19, 2000 06:33:54 AM new
I can't beleve that they would cancel your bid when they let other obviously criminal bids continue. My favorite this week is the Adobe collection for $1.00. All full versions.
I have several games that were bundled with my Diamond video card that are marked not for resale. I think that this should be like the tag on your mattress, the buyer has the right to remove it. If I want to sell my Diamond software, it is mine to sell. What the law should prevent is a store from separating tha two and selling the two...I hope
posted on February 19, 2000 10:41:23 AM new
And what if you purchase a copy of a marked"not for sale"version of hardware in a thrift store..You paid money for it ,but you had full knowledge when you bought it that you were buying and illegal item..If you buy a Stereo out of the trunk of a car in the alley do you have the right to resell it?? you again know it is an illegal purchase and haven't aright to buy it or resell it..
Today bootleg CDs and what will be OK tommorrow?????
posted on February 19, 2000 07:58:41 PM new
An Illegial item? Not hardly. Used, yes. And the original owner may have agreed not to sell it, or even give it away...I don't know what their agreement was.
I made no such agreement and it's pretty clear that I have every right to buy and sell used software, and the publisher's know it.
They may finally get their way when they can eliminate the physical media and sell you just the data: like in downloading their softs from the net. I can see them making an agreement with the buyer that this is for one machine, one person, not to be transferred, etc. But when they sell it on a physical disk, the history of our civilization says that somebody owns that and can resell it.
posted on February 24, 2000 11:35:16 PM new
Get this one I spent over $100 on mini perfumes at a company online only to find out every bottle said "NOT FOR RESALE"