Home  >  Community  >  Yahoo Auctions  >  Reserve Revealed - YOUR OPINION


<< previous topic post new topic post reply next topic >>
 depottoo
 
posted on August 2, 1999 11:17:00 PM new
I would like to start this thread for users of reserve bids. What is your opinion of the reserve being revealed if it has not been met within 24 hours of closing?? Do you like it or wish they would not reveal it, the way ebay & amazon keep it private.
 
 gawooley
 
posted on August 2, 1999 12:05:00 PM new
I like the 24 hour disclosure...

There are only two times that I bid on an item that has a reserve...the opening bid, to track the auction...or after the reserve has been met. I don't like "reserve" auctions...I would rather know what the minimum that a seller will take is...and would rather a seller just start the auction at that price.

After wasting my time on a couple of auctions when I was a "newbie", I adopted this policy.

For that reason I don't use reserve auctions as a seller...because of my personal "distaste" for them.

I'm sure there will be other (and better informed) opinions from sellers who use "reserves" concerning your actual question...and I've heard the arguments FOR using reserves...but I just don't like them!

------------------
George
Founder
The Seller Zone

clubs.yahoo.com/clubs/thesellerzone


[This message has been edited by gawooley (edited August 02, 1999).]
 

 kimbo
 
posted on August 3, 1999 11:28:00 PM new
To use a reserve or not, that is a tough ?,
because as a seller I can see the times when
it works well on Ebay. On Yahoo, I rarely
use them, as it is not clear enough for the
bidder. I never keep my reserve(s) when I
use them, a secret, if anyone really wants
to know, I will tell. The big problem with
the way it is done at Yahoo, is it should
be in red, where it can't be missed, RESERVE
NOT MET, as the way it is now, it is way too
hard to see when one is being used at all.
I don't see why the reserve need be revealed,
unless it is met either, but that doesn't
bother me as much as my first reason why I
won't use them on Yahoo. I don't want to
confuse bidders. The whole idea of using a
reserve should not be to trick or confuse
bidders but rather to entice them into bidding and hope the reserve gets met anyway.
 
 jamaicajohn
 
posted on August 13, 1999 03:38:00 PM new
I have sent Yahoo!'s suggestion box a message that it needs to be more obvious that there's an unmet reserve. I use reserves on eBay because they work and there are enough bidders and enough action to get the bidding up to the reserve.

OTOH, on Yahoo! I'm lucky to get 1 or 2 bids for the same item so I just forget the reserve and start higher.

I think the 24 hour rule should be an option set at the time the auction is listed. There are different reasons for using reserves and sometimes it's not appropriate for revealing the amount.

John.
 

 sunshinenow
 
posted on August 14, 1999 05:01:00 PM new
This is only my opinion but I don't believe reserves should be used. If you are going to sell something start the item at the amount that you are willing to let the item go at. Ads that have a reserve and then state the reserve in their description are absolutely silly! Reserves just waste everybody's time! If you don't want to sell it - don't list it! I sell sheepskins and jewellery and I've never listed with a reserve!
 
 jamaicajohn
 
posted on August 15, 1999 03:31:00 PM new
I used to think reserves were silly till I tried relisting items. Instead of a $29 starting price with no bids I'd start at $1 with a $29 reserve and they would hit the reserve in 2 or 3 bids. I don't know why it works but it does. (Maybe it's product-specific).

As to revealing reserves, I think it should be an option when the auction is submitted.

Just saw one silly one though. On an item that normally goes for $70-$90, the reserve got revealed today -- $1500! Either the guy had no clue (although there are about 10 of the items up for bid) or he mistyped the wrong number in the wrong field.

John.
 

 ph44
 
posted on August 27, 1999 05:38:22 AM new
My personal experience with reserve prices is minimal as I usually begin my auctions with the minimum price I am willing to take for the item. ... I was approached by a seller who suggested that if I had an item I wished to price but not sell I could list it with a high reserve and then wait and see how much people were willing to spend on it . I have also heard that some people post high reserves and then offer the item to the highest bidder and therefore bypass the final fees due the Auction site. This practice doesn't fly with Amazon because they do not reveal the idenity of high bidders unless the reserve has been met..good for them. Ebay's new reserve pricing will protect them and the fee will be refunded to the seller if the reserve is met.
 
 jamaicajohn
 
posted on August 31, 1999 02:40:15 PM new
And it's kind of dumb to do that on Yahoo! since there are no fees to avoid.

John.

---
"I've read dozens of books about heroes and crooks and I've learned much from both of their styles" Jimmy Buffett, Son of a Son of a Sailor
 
 space_dog
 
posted on September 1, 1999 06:48:28 PM new
I've been a seller on eBay for about the past six months (not sure if that makes me new to it or not). I strongly agree with jamaicajohn in that an item listed at $1.00 with a $29.00 reserve than an item starting at $29.00.

It goes back to the fact that people want the best possible deal. A scenario for you:

You are looking for a specific item. The item is worth $29.00 and you are willing to pay $29.00 for it. You search the auction site and find two such items. The first is at $1.00 and but has an undisclosed reserve price. The second is at $29.00, the maximum you are willing to pay for the item. Which item do you bid on? I submit that *most* people will bid on the $1.00 item and hope that the seller put the reserve at $20.00 instead of $29.00. The second item will receive far fewer bids and might not even selln because people that are interested in it are bidding on the first auction. This is why sellers like reserves. Start high and get no bids or start low with a reserve and get bids.

My two cents...
 
 
<< previous topic post new topic post reply next topic >>

Jump to

All content © 1998-2026  Vendio all rights reserved. Vendio Services, Inc.™, Simply Powerful eCommerce, Smart Services for Smart Sellers, Buy Anywhere. Sell Anywhere. Start Here.™ and The Complete Auction Management Solution™ are trademarks of Vendio. Auction slogans and artwork are copyrights © of their respective owners. Vendio accepts no liability for the views or information presented here.

The Vendio free online store builder is easy to use and includes a free shopping cart to help you can get started in minutes!