Home  >  Community  >  Yahoo Auctions  >  Winning Bid Not Accepted


<< previous topic post new topic post reply next topic >>
 parsec78
 
posted on November 4, 1999 10:32:20 AM new

I was the winning bidder for $9.99 on an item which had a
"Buy Price" of $33.00. There was no reserve on this auction.
After the auction closed, I contacted the merchant who
offered to sell me the item for $33.00, their "minimum price."
They claimed that this was a Reserve Auction and if it wasn't
shown, it was a mistake.

I feel that they should honor their obligation to sell at the
winning bid. If it was a mistake, it was theirs.

Has anyone had a similar experience? I'm not sure how to proceed.
I wrote the seller that I would leave negative feedback but haven't
done it yet. They have all positive feedback up to this point.
Should I report them to Yahoo? Should I post in "Buyer Beware,"
with a message to the seller to participate in the discussion?

Thanks for any feedback.

 
 camachinist
 
posted on November 4, 1999 12:38:20 PM new
Hi,
Just checked your rating on Yahoo....My 02.... You've got an excellent reputation and that's worth preserving. Was the item worth the 33.00 buy price? As I understand this, you are under no obligation to buy...but you feel the seller has an obligation to sell the item to you at your bid.

Think about it...why would a seller have a 33.00 buy price on a no reserve auction with less than that price as a minimum bid?? It doesn't make sense. Maybe they did make a mistake...maybe Yahoo screwed up.

Does the seller have a good reputation?? If so, I would tend to think an error was made.

Personally, I wouldn't force the issue. One last question...were you the only bidder on this auction?
---
Success is where opportunity and preparation meet.
 
 rustybore
 
posted on November 4, 1999 03:20:10 PM new
parsec78, some clarifaction

The "BUY PRICE" is basicly the reserve price.

The differance being that when the "BUY PRICE" is reached, the auction is ended right away. done deal, finished, over.

With a "RESERVE" however, the auction continues, permiting bidding on the item above and beyond that "RESERVE".

With a $33.00 BUY PRICE, and your bid of $9.99, you are not entitled to win the item,

Sorry...
 
 parsec78
 
posted on November 4, 1999 04:39:55 PM new
camachinist, was the $33.00 buy price worth it? That is subjective.
I have won similar items for way less than that - lucky, I guess. It's possible that the seller made
a mistake in not setting a reserve.
And yes, I was the only bidder.

rustybore, I don't agree with your
definition of a "Buy Price." Following is from the Yahoo Auctions Bidder Guide:
The Buy Price is the price at which the seller is willing to "close" an auction. The auction closes automatically when a bidder meets the seller's buy price. However, it is not necessary for the Buy Price to be met in order for the auction to close successfully.

I'm not going to force the issue; in fact I probably won't even leave
negative feedback! I just wanted to
see what other people had to say about the sellers attitude. (They
emailed me to not bid in anymore of their auctions!)

 
 justmare
 
posted on November 4, 1999 09:15:58 PM new
Being new in yahoo myself, I was kinda confused to all the ways to list. I had been listing just like I did in ebay with just the min bid as start. Earlier today I thought I'd try the buy price feature..I started several things like 30.00 and had the buy price at 60.00 for instance. After I did several of these, I got thinking about it and thought something don't seem right. I went back and read the features and it says the buy price is used to where when some reaches that the auction is over. But in the same paragraph it says if you don't want to sell for less then the buy price, then you need to use the reserve feature with it and set it for the amount of the buy price.
I went to change each auction to add the reserve price but found I had to end them and start over. So I relisted them with making the reserve and the buy price the same.

I wouldn't neg this seller, they are just not understanding the feature. You might want to nicely point it out to her, that the buy price is not the same as a reserve. Since she is probably new too, I wouldn't hold her to the price you won it at, as it most likely was a mistake or misunderstanding of the feature.

From the way I now understand it, by listing the reserve with the same price as the buy price, once the reserve is met, the auction will end at that time since it is the same as the buy price.

With all of us so used to ebay, its taking a little while for us to get used to all the different formats of all the other auction sites.
 
 rustybore
 
posted on November 5, 1999 01:04:52 PM new
Hummm.....Interesting, I will need to rethink my perception of "buy price"

I kinda felt that if the reserve and buy price were the same, you would have, on the auction side, basicly a zShop type listing, that is, first bid is the winning bid.

I have wonderd why sellers didnt do this more often, yet many sellers jumped at the chance to do essentialy the same thing over on the zShop side.

Go Figure...
 
 justmare
 
posted on November 5, 1999 02:23:27 PM new
yep, thats what it becomes a zhop listing. I have sold 4 things in zshop so far and only have listed no more then 10 things at a time. No matter where I go they all seem to be slow..no slower then ebay for me at this point. But what a difference in fees. I ran into another seller at the Po today and one at UPS and they both said sales SUCK on ebay, they too have started going to other places.


 
 nata
 
posted on November 7, 1999 12:23:48 AM new
I had the same exp tonight - Got announcement on my item that there was a winner.. @ 11.00 but the buy price was 18.50
Now, I thought it was treated like a dead ended reserve. In other words if the bid reaches buy price - auction is over. If it doesn't reach buy price - no winner. I wrote to Yahoo and bidder and waiting on ans as we speak. Hope this helps
 
 RODSCARDS
 
posted on November 7, 1999 12:24:12 PM new
Maybe this will help clear up some things.there are several ways to do buy price auctions. one is When an item is listed as a buy price auction that is the price you can get it for. Example I list sports photos and they are all buy price auctions. I start the bidding at $3.75 and the buy price is $3.75 so when you bid you got it. You can also start the bidding lower and have the buy higher. example. the bidding starts at $2.00 the buy price is $10.00 when the bidding hits $10.00 that item sells, but if the auction closes and the high bid was only $4.00 then the item sells for $4.00. If the seller wanted to get a min of $10.00 they need to set a reserve. The moral of the story is, if there was no reserve then the item sold for $4.00
 
 
<< previous topic post new topic post reply next topic >>

Jump to

All content © 1998-2026  Vendio all rights reserved. Vendio Services, Inc.™, Simply Powerful eCommerce, Smart Services for Smart Sellers, Buy Anywhere. Sell Anywhere. Start Here.™ and The Complete Auction Management Solution™ are trademarks of Vendio. Auction slogans and artwork are copyrights © of their respective owners. Vendio accepts no liability for the views or information presented here.

The Vendio free online store builder is easy to use and includes a free shopping cart to help you can get started in minutes!