Home  >  Community  >  The eBay Outlook  >  Buyer agrees to send $5 to Planned Parenthood


<< previous topic post new topic post reply next topic >>
 This topic is 3 pages long: 1 2 3 new
 femme
 
posted on October 27, 2000 05:10:26 AM new

HCQ said:

Cagrrl - Exactly - unless, of course, the seller's intent is to weed out "undesirable" bidders (i.e., those who differ philosophially).

Bingo!!!!

sg52,

A requirement to log on to a web site...

Legal by eBay rules?

That part of the wording leads me to say no to your question.

I have no problem with their intention, as it is their business, but it is the element of blackmail that is offensive.

I would prefer, if they want to make a statement, that they just say that $5 from each sale will be donated to (in this case) Planned Parenthood.



[ edited by femme on Oct 27, 2000 05:14 AM ]
 
 sg52
 
posted on October 27, 2000 11:19:08 AM new
Then if a seller tacks a $5 "handling fee" onto his shipping charges, ebay won't mind?

Precisely.

We might contrive a grey answer, where the items end up being sold for $.01, with a $8.20 priority mail shipping/handling, but I predict that eBay would not disallow even that.

eBay has no beef whatsoever with a $5 handling fee in any normal circumstance.

sg52

 
 sg52
 
posted on October 27, 2000 11:21:07 AM new
it is the element of blackmail that is offensive.

No blackmail was intended as part of the suggestion.

Simply, "this is a term of completing the transaction", along with the implied, "if you don't want to do this, don't bid".

As much as I tend to avoid auctions which have any such terms in them, I don't find any hint of blackmail.

sg52

 
 sg52
 
posted on October 27, 2000 11:24:15 AM new
unless, of course, the seller's intent is to weed out "undesirable" bidders (- those who differ philosophially.

Is there any rule against that?

sg52

 
 HartCottageQuilts
 
posted on October 27, 2000 11:48:08 AM new
No blackmail was intended as part of the suggestion. Simply, "this is a term of completing the transaction", along with the implied, "if you don't want to do this, don't bid". As much as I tend to avoid auctions which have any such terms in them, I don't find any hint of blackmail.

I concur entirely. Blackmail is "extortion or coercion by threats especially of public exposure or criminal prosecution". I see no threats whatsoever. Nor is this purely extortion - obtaining "by force, intimidation, or undue or illegal power". Force? Who's forced to bid? Intimidation? Surely you jest. No "power," neither "illegal" nor "undue", since the bidder can simply hit the "back" button and be done with this seller.

This sort of policy isn't blackmail. It's just DUMB - unless your reason for selling is not to make money, but to prove some political point. I can see a whole lot of more cost-efficient ways to do that.

And no, I don't see anything in ebay rules barring sellers from refusing to sell to any bidders they consider "undesirable".






 
   This topic is 3 pages long: 1 2 3 new
<< previous topic post new topic post reply next topic >>

Jump to

All content © 1998-2026  Vendio all rights reserved. Vendio Services, Inc.™, Simply Powerful eCommerce, Smart Services for Smart Sellers, Buy Anywhere. Sell Anywhere. Start Here.™ and The Complete Auction Management Solution™ are trademarks of Vendio. Auction slogans and artwork are copyrights © of their respective owners. Vendio accepts no liability for the views or information presented here.

The Vendio free online store builder is easy to use and includes a free shopping cart to help you can get started in minutes!